If you love chewy, flavorful bagels with a crispy golden crust, this sourdough bagel recipe is for you! Unlike regular bagels, which rely on commercial yeast, these bagels use a natural sourdough starter, creating a deeper, more complex flavor. Plus, with a little patience and the right techniques, you’ll achieve that perfect bakery-style chewiness at home.
In this guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know to make the best sourdough bagels from scratch. You’ll learn about essential ingredients, step-by-step preparation, common mistakes to avoid, and expert tips for getting the ideal texture. Whether you’re a seasoned baker or just starting your sourdough journey, this recipe will walk you through the process with ease.
So, get your sourdough starter ready, and let’s dive into the world of homemade sourdough bagels!
Table of Contents
Introduction to Sourdough Bagels
What Makes a Sourdough Bagel Different?
A sourdough bagel recipe follows the same basic bagel-making process as traditional ones but swaps out commercial yeast for a natural sourdough starter. This change not only adds depth of flavor but also results in a slightly chewier texture. The fermentation process takes longer, but the benefits are worth it:
✔ A tangy, rich taste that you won’t get from regular bagels.
✔ A more digestible and gut-friendly treat, thanks to natural fermentation.
✔ A beautifully golden crust with an airy yet chewy interior.
The Benefits of Using a Sourdough Starter
Why go through the extra effort of using a sourdough starter? Well, aside from the amazing texture and flavor, there are a few other perks:
- No commercial yeast needed – Perfect for those who prefer a naturally leavened dough.
- Healthier digestion – The fermentation process breaks down gluten, making it easier on your stomach.
- Extended freshness – Sourdough bagels stay softer and fresher for longer than yeast-based ones.
If you don’t already have a sourdough starter, don’t worry! You can either make your own at home (it takes about a week) or ask a fellow baker for some.
What You’ll Learn in This Recipe Guide
In the next sections, we’ll go over:
✔ The key ingredients needed for a perfect sourdough bagel recipe.
✔ Step-by-step instructions, from mixing the dough to shaping and baking.
✔ Common mistakes to avoid so your bagels turn out perfectly chewy and golden brown.
✔ Flavor variations and toppings to customize your bagels just the way you like them.
Essential Ingredients and Tools for the Best Sourdough Bagels
Key Ingredients for a Perfect Sourdough Bagel Recipe
A great sourdough bagel recipe starts with the right ingredients. Here’s what you’ll need:
- Bread Flour – High-protein flour is essential for creating the chewy texture that makes bagels special.
- Sourdough Starter – An active, bubbly sourdough starter gives the bagels their signature tangy flavor.
- Water – Lukewarm water helps activate the starter and hydrates the dough properly.
- Salt – Improves the flavor and reinforces the dough’s structure.
- Sweetener – A touch of honey or malt syrup adds subtle sweetness and helps with browning.
The Importance of a Healthy Sourdough Starter
Your sourdough starter is the backbone of this recipe. If it’s not active and bubbly, your bagels won’t rise properly. Here’s how to ensure your starter is ready:
✔ Feed it 4-6 hours before using it, so it reaches peak activity.
✔ If your starter doubles in size after feeding, it’s strong enough.
✔ Use warm water (not hot) to mix with the starter for better fermentation.
Must-Have Tools for Bagel Making at Home
While bagels can be made with basic kitchen tools, a few extras make the process smoother:
✔ Stand Mixer – Speeds up kneading, making dough handling easier.
✔ Baking Stone or Sheet – Helps achieve that golden, crispy crust.
✔ Slotted Spoon – Essential for boiling bagels before baking.
✔ Dutch Oven (Optional) – Great for achieving bakery-style crust.
With these ingredients and tools ready, let’s move on to the step-by-step guide for making the best sourdough bagels!
Step-by-Step Sourdough Bagel Recipe
Preparing the Dough: Mixing and Kneading
- In a large bowl, combine sourdough starter, water, honey, and bread flour.
- Mix until a shaggy dough forms, then let it rest for 30 minutes (autolyse).
- Add salt, then knead the dough for 8-10 minutes until smooth and elastic.
- Place the dough in a greased bowl, cover, and let it bulk ferment for 8-12 hours at room temperature.
Bulk Fermentation: Letting the Dough Rise Overnight
✔ The dough should double in size after fermenting.
✔ If your kitchen is cold, place the dough in a warm spot (around 75-78°F).
✔ For extra depth of flavor, refrigerate the dough for 12-24 hours after fermentation.
Shaping Bagels: The Right Technique for a Perfect Hole
- Divide the dough into equal portions (about 90-100g each).
- Roll each piece into a smooth ball, then poke a hole in the center.
- Stretch the hole to about 2 inches wide—it will shrink slightly during baking.
Boiling the Bagels: Why It’s Essential for Texture
Boiling gives bagels their distinct chewiness. Here’s how to do it right:
✔ Bring a pot of water to a rolling boil, then add a tablespoon of baking soda or barley malt syrup.
✔ Drop the bagels in, boiling for 30-60 seconds per side.
✔ The longer the boil, the chewier the bagels will be.
Baking for the Perfect Crust and Chewy Interior
- Preheat the oven to 425°F (220°C).
- Place boiled bagels on a parchment-lined baking sheet.
- If adding toppings (sesame, poppy seeds, etc.), brush bagels with egg wash and sprinkle them on.
- Bake for 20-25 minutes, or until deep golden brown.
That’s it! Fresh, chewy, and absolutely delicious sourdough bagels straight from your oven.
I couldn’t find any relevant internal linking opportunities from RecipeKook for the sourdough bagel recipe. However, if you’re interested in more homemade baked goods, you might find their mini cheesecake recipe or chocolate chip muffin guide helpful.
Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
What Happens If Your Dough Doesn’t Rise?
One of the biggest challenges in a sourdough bagel recipe is when the dough doesn’t rise properly. If this happens, here’s what to check:
✔ Is your sourdough starter active? If it’s sluggish, feed it and wait until it doubles in size before using it.
✔ Did you ferment in a cold environment? If your kitchen is chilly, try fermenting the dough in a slightly warmer spot (around 75-78°F).
✔ Was the hydration correct? If your dough feels too stiff, add a tablespoon of warm water to help fermentation.
Overproofing vs. Underproofing: How to Tell the Difference
Bagels rely on perfect fermentation. But how do you know if you’ve gone too far—or not far enough?
- Underproofed dough: If your bagels are dense and don’t expand much in the oven, they needed more time to ferment.
- Overproofed dough: If they collapse or have a wrinkled crust after baking, they proofed for too long.
✔ Fix it: The poke test! Gently press a piece of dough—if it springs back slowly, it’s ready. If it springs back too quickly, let it proof longer.
Fixing Dough That’s Too Sticky or Too Dry
✔ If the dough is too sticky, add a sprinkle of flour while kneading.
✔ If the dough is too dry, add a splash of water and knead gently.
✔ The perfect bagel dough should be firm but slightly tacky—not dry or overly sticky.
If you’re interested in more homemade baked goods, you might find their mini cheesecake recipe or chocolate chip muffin guide helpful.
Tips for Achieving the Perfect Sourdough Bagel Texture
How Long to Ferment for the Best Flavor
A longer fermentation process develops the deep, tangy flavor that makes a sourdough bagel recipe stand out. Here’s a simple timeline:
✔ 8-12 hours at room temperature for standard fermentation.
✔ 12-24 hours in the fridge for extra depth and chewiness.
✔ Too long? If dough ferments beyond 24 hours, it may become overly sour and weak.
Why Hydration Levels Matter in Bagel Dough
✔ Lower hydration (55-60%) creates a dense, chewy texture—ideal for classic bagels.
✔ Higher hydration (65-70%) gives a softer crumb but less chew.
✔ If you’re a beginner, aim for 60% hydration for the perfect balance.
The Role of Steam and Humidity in Baking
✔ Steam helps bagels develop a shiny crust—try placing a small dish of water in the oven.
✔ If your bagels bake up too hard, reduce baking time or lightly mist them with water before baking.
✔ Want that New York-style chew? Boil bagels for 60-90 seconds per side before baking.
Flavor Variations and Toppings
Classic Bagel Toppings: Sesame, Poppy Seeds, and More
A sourdough bagel recipe can be easily customized with classic toppings to enhance texture and flavor. Before baking, brush each bagel with an egg wash to help toppings stick. Some popular choices include:
✔ Sesame seeds – Adds a light, nutty crunch.
✔ Poppy seeds – A traditional choice with a mild, earthy flavor.
✔ Everything bagel seasoning – A blend of garlic, onion, sesame, and poppy seeds for a savory kick.
✔ Coarse salt – A simple yet delicious way to bring out the bagel’s natural flavors.
Adding Herbs, Spices, and Mix-Ins to Your Dough
Want to take your sourdough bagel recipe up a notch? Try mixing these ingredients into the dough:
✔ Garlic and herb – Add minced garlic, dried rosemary, or thyme for a fragrant twist.
✔ Cinnamon and raisins – A touch of cinnamon and soaked raisins make for a slightly sweet variation.
✔ Cheddar and jalapeño – Shredded cheese and diced jalapeños add a deliciously spicy contrast.
Sweet vs. Savory Bagels: Experimenting with Flavors
While most bagels lean savory, a sourdough bagel recipe can be easily adapted for sweet versions:
✔ Chocolate chip – Mix in dark chocolate chips for a dessert-like treat.
✔ Blueberry – Fresh or dried blueberries give a fruity burst of flavor.
✔ Honey and oats – A drizzle of honey and a sprinkle of oats create a lightly sweet bagel.
With these variations, you can enjoy a different type of sourdough bagel every time!
Serving and Storing Your Sourdough Bagels
Best Ways to Serve Freshly Baked Bagels
Nothing beats a freshly baked sourdough bagel! Here are some delicious ways to enjoy them:
✔ Toasted with butter – A simple yet irresistible way to enjoy bagels.
✔ With cream cheese and smoked salmon – A classic New York-style bagel pairing.
✔ Egg and cheese sandwich – Slice a bagel in half and add scrambled eggs, cheese, and bacon.
✔ Avocado toast bagel – Spread mashed avocado and top with cherry tomatoes and feta cheese.
How to Store and Reheat for Maximum Freshness
Bagels taste best on the day they’re baked, but you can keep them fresh with proper storage:
✔ Room Temperature: Store in a paper bag for up to 2 days. Avoid plastic, as it makes bagels soggy.
✔ Refrigeration: Not recommended, as it dries out the bagels quickly.
✔ Freezing: Slice bagels before freezing in an airtight bag. They’ll last up to 3 months.
Freezing Sourdough Bagels: Do’s and Don’ts
✔ Do freeze bagels individually wrapped for easy grab-and-go use.
✔ Do reheat frozen bagels by toasting or baking at 350°F for 5-7 minutes.
✔ Don’t microwave bagels—this makes them rubbery instead of chewy.
With these serving and storage tips, you can enjoy your homemade sourdough bagel recipe anytime!
FAQs – Answering Popular Questions
What is the biggest mistake you can make with your sourdough starter?
The most common mistake when making a sourdough bagel recipe is using an inactive starter. If your starter isn’t bubbly and strong, your bagels won’t rise properly. To avoid this:
✔ Feed your starter regularly – At least once a day if kept at room temperature.
✔ Use it at peak activity – A well-fed starter should double in size within 4-6 hours.
✔ Avoid overfeeding – Too many feedings without discarding weaken the natural yeast.
If your starter isn’t rising well, try placing it in a warm spot (75-80°F) for better fermentation.
Are there sourdough bagels?
Absolutely! A sourdough bagel recipe is just like a traditional bagel recipe, but instead of using commercial yeast, it relies on a natural sourdough starter for leavening. This method creates a richer flavor and a chewier texture while being easier to digest.
What is the secret to good sourdough bread?
The secret to a great sourdough bagel recipe (or any sourdough bread) lies in these key factors:
✔ Strong, active starter – It should be bubbly and well-fed before mixing the dough.
✔ Long fermentation – A slow rise improves the bagel’s chewiness and flavor.
✔ Proper hydration – The right water-to-flour ratio ensures a firm yet pliable dough.
✔ Boiling before baking – This is crucial for achieving that iconic chewy crust.
Why are my sourdough bagels so chewy?
A chewy texture is one of the best features of a sourdough bagel recipe! However, if your bagels are too dense, a few things might have gone wrong:
✔ Over-kneading the dough – Too much kneading can create a tight crumb.
✔ Boiling too long – A longer boil creates extra chewiness. Try reducing the time to 30 seconds per side.
✔ Underproofing the dough – If the dough doesn’t ferment long enough, the bagels won’t rise properly.
For a lighter but still chewy bagel, ensure a proper rise and don’t overwork the dough.
Final Thoughts – Why You Should Try This Sourdough Bagel Recipe
Making a sourdough bagel recipe from scratch is incredibly rewarding. Not only do you get bakery-quality bagels at home, but you also enjoy the unique depth of flavor that only naturally fermented dough can offer.
The best part? You can customize your bagels however you like—whether you prefer classic sesame, hearty everything seasoning, or even a sweet cinnamon-raisin twist. Plus, by using a sourdough starter, you’re skipping processed yeast and making a healthier, gut-friendly version of your favorite bagel.
With the right techniques and patience, you’ll create bagels that are chewy on the inside, crispy on the outside, and packed with flavor. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced baker, this recipe will guide you through the process step by step.
So why not give this sourdough bagel recipe a try? Once you taste the results, you’ll never want store-bought bagels again!